Lohan vs. Schiffer: Who Wore It Better?

Image by Splash News

Wouldn't it be nice to be able to wear Chanel for just a night out? Well life is good for supermodel Claudia Schiffer and Lindsay Lohan who were both photographed rocking the same Chanel mini. Schiffer was snapped wearing the dress with blacker tights back in London in February while Lohan opted lighter tights with her Miu Miu shoes on the red-carpet in LA last week.

They both looked great, but who really rocked the dress? You decide!

Get Lindsay Lohan Breaking News!

Follow Hollyscoop on Twitter

Twitter / Facebook

Facebook / RSS

RSS

Lindsay Lohan , Fashion Hits & Misses

Twitter

Facebook

Yahoo Buzz

MySpace

Digg

The Kids’ Choice Awards Gift...

JT Back in LA

Check out more on Lindsay Lohan

Report: Lindsay Lohan Facing Ban from India

Michael Lohan Blames Heart Attack on Troubles With Ex

Lindsay Lohan Quizzed About Her Sexual Orientation

Lindsay Lohan Suing E*Trade Commercial

Report: Lindsay Lohan Fired from Ungaro

Reader Comments

3:08PM 07/23/07 Elle

not a fan of lohan, but i think she looks better. the tights are horrid on both of them though. && to everyone who didnt choose lindsay because shes a "whore" next time-think of a better excuse. its about the outfit not if shes wearing underwear or not.

11:16PM 04/24/07 bvbv

claudia rox

8:06PM 04/15/07 Andréa

Claudia, no doubt! Neither Lindsay nor anyone would defeat her. She'll always be the best. Those darker thights of Claudia match incredibly the outfit! Lindsay's thights make her look vulgar (even more than she already is). And she definetely should've seen that there is a problem with the chains of her dress. Besides, Claudia's watch and purse make the difference. And her hair is amazing! Claudia is the best ever! I love her!

11:40AM 04/07/07 Melanie

I have to say Claudia. Both are beautiful, but Claudia more so!

0:21PM 04/02/07 amy

Lo looks wayyyy better she got a HOTT BOD

11:23AM 04/02/07 Hazel

OMG It has to be lindsay her hair so lucious and silky and plus she has more of a figure to flant th outfit unlike claudia she is like a flat ironing board in tht dress!

11:16AM 04/02/07 nat

not a big fan of lohan, but she definitely wears it better than schiffer

8:53AM 04/02/07 Candeefloss

def lindsay, claudia jus looks scrawny an boy like in it

7:13AM 04/02/07 Sam

claudia..blohan looks like a fatso...big meat legs

6:35AM 04/02/07 Batman

Lindsay Lohan looks beautiful. She wins easily

5:30AM 04/02/07 x-teen

Lindsay looks much better !!

4:34AM 04/02/07 Holland

Claudia, by far. Although it's the same oufit, one wears it with grace and actually makes it looks classy while the other looks a 5 dollar hooker in it.

4:00AM 04/02/07 ali

LOHAN for sure

3:31AM 04/02/07 JayZ

Claudia of coz, considering she's a bit older than LL, and still looks a lot fresher and not to mention taller. And supermodel is supermodel, Claudia just has much more personality and charisma to go with it. CLaudia ROCKS!!

0:25AM 04/02/07 SEX with HUMAN FECES

I like girls who's PUSSY and ASSHOLES STINK. I LIKE girls who dont wash there STINKY ASSHOLE I BET Avril Lavigne's PUSSY and ASSHOLES STINK IF i stick my finger in Avril Lavigne's asshole will it stink? i bet it will stink i bet it will have that STINKY CHEESY SMELL I bet lavigne's ASSHOLE STINKS I want lavigne's FECES to soil every POUR of my NUDE BODY I want to eat Avril Lavigne's STINKY ASSHOLE while she is shiting her STINKY BROWN HUMAN FECES

11:56PM 04/01/07 mezza

Don't like the dress much but La Lohan wins by miles.

10:04PM 04/01/07 Chigglesworth

I hate Lindsey, but I think she looks better. Claudia's tights blend too much into the dress.. and she looks shapeless in it. Not to mention, Lohan has really cute shoes to go with the outfits.

9:15PM 04/01/07 ya

La Lohan is looking mighty fine. Claudia, the hair the tights... Not as good.

7:32PM 04/01/07 jules

No contest at all...Claudia. And you all can see it. If you said LL then you are a moronic jack---.

7:17PM 04/01/07 mark

CLAUDIA ALL THE WAY LL is a whore

6:59PM 04/01/07 Scoot

Lindsay!

4:50PM 04/01/07 aloha

Claudia is better, look how the chains on the front lie. Linds looks like she squeezed her boobs into that frock- the chains are stretched unnaturally- Claudia wins.

4:29PM 04/01/07 Tony Snow will die from colon cancer

Tony Snow Will die of colon cancer he has entered a Hospice

4:12PM 04/01/07 lints

none, look at those fat pig thighs. yuck, hate lindsay

3:32PM 04/01/07 Amanda

Lindsay looks hot, much better, wow the dress not that exciting the only differ is the stockings vs tights, but the hair and shoes much better on Lindsay wooot woot lol

3:01PM 04/01/07 LL

Lohan wins.

2:45PM 04/01/07 Ann from Montreal

At least Claudia is a real lady and probably has underwear on. Lindsay, on the other hand, it is unfortunate that someone as skanky as her would get to wear such beautiful creations. Claudia brings her grace to the dress while all Lindsay leaves are bodily fluid stains!!

2:39PM 04/01/07 Kacey

Lindsay looks better by a landslide! She looks very sexy and voluptuous. This is one of the few times I have thought she was just more than pretty.

2:33PM 04/01/07 agwklhgkhl

LINDSAY looks fabulous.

0:49PM 04/01/07 Flo

the dress is really ugly, but Lindsay wore it better

0:48PM 04/01/07 lori

No way lindsay does not look better. Claudia wore it much better because the black tights match the dress much more than the grandma tights lindsay has been wearing lately

0:46PM 04/01/07 natalie

LINDSAY.