Make Hollyscoop your homepage

HS Mobile

Entertainment

Photos

Videos

Movies

Music

Style

HotSpots

Who Wore It Best?

May 22, 2007

Image by Splash News

Both Nicky Hilton and Hilary Duff own the cute Petra Zillia jumper.

Hilton wore the short dress for a night on the town while the Duffster opted to wear it with tights while hosting TRL.

Both looked cute but who really owned the dress?

Don't MISS out on Breaking News!

Follow Hollyscoop on Twitter

Twitter / Facebook

Facebook / RSS

RSS

Fashion Hits & Misses

Twitter

Facebook

Yahoo Buzz

MySpace

Digg

Maroon 5's New Album...

Light It Up

Check out more on Fashion Hits & Misses

Giving Britney a Breather

2007 American Music Awards: Arrivals

Renee Feels Bad For Young Stars

Paris Is A Mess At The Spike Awards

Who Rocked the Frock?

Reader Comments

7:36PM 05/31/07 nia

hilary... the other girl looks like a stick

10:42PM 05/25/07 sexy

hilary but what's wromg with those tights???

6:03AM 05/23/07 Diane

I'm not a Nicky Hilton fan, either, but I think she's rocking this look! Looks like I'm in the way minority, though.

7:27PM 05/22/07 DivaG81

Duff - she's working the black tights with the dress; too much skin with Nicky - and her legs look funky

6:09PM 05/22/07 godless

Hillary without a doubt nailed it.

5:27PM 05/22/07 lala

nicky hilton!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

4:38PM 05/22/07 anonymous

Neither. It's ugly no matter who's wearing it.

4:19PM 05/22/07 robin

i don't care if it's a homeless man wearing a fanny pack, he'll always win in a "who looks better" contest if any of the hiltons are involved.

3:48PM 05/22/07 fdfd

hilary looks better with it with her hairstyle and earring..but i think she should have ditched those tights

3:37PM 05/22/07 Cynthia

I whole-heartedly concur. Duff FTW!

3:00PM 05/22/07 La Chat

why do they always pick ugly dresses to compare and contrast?

2:48PM 05/22/07 jenn

im with both of you! The Duffster! Even though it does look better without tights. I wouldnt choose nicky even if it did look good just cause shes fugly

2:40PM 05/22/07 z

hilary looks better obviously nicky is disgusting so she makes even the cutest dress look digusting

2:07PM 05/22/07 Marilyn

Miss Duff... hands down.