Twelve became eleven on American Idol on Thursday night after America voted off Karen Rodriguez.
Her version of "Love Will Lead You Back," clearly didn't do anything to win her a spot in the final race because the judges chose not to save her, although Randy pointed out that the decision wasn't unanimous.
Also in the bottom three were Haley and Naima, who gave less than stellar performances this week.
The Black Eyed Peas performed, and American Idol season 9 champ Lee DeWyze introduced his new single, "Beautiful Like You."
Were you surprised to see Karen go? Who are you rooting for?